There are nearly half a million podcasts. But with so many options, how you find the top-performing shows? Find out in this week’s episode of The Media Roundtable.

Kyle Jelinek (VP, Client Services, Oxford Road) hosts Hilary Shafer (SVP, Creator Relationship Partner, Oxford Road) to break down all the learnings from our November ORBIT report, which comes out today. Together, they share their insights on smart media buying, creator customization, and costly CPMs. Let’s dive in.

“Here’s why ORBIT is so different compared to a lot of other rankers out there: A lot of times, we’re just looking sheerly at size, scale, and volume. But ORBIT looks at what’s driving action. ” – Hilary Shafer (SVP, Creator Relationship Partner, Oxford Road)

Buy the Easy Way, Learn the Hard Way – When brands place their own media buys, they generally pick an “on the nose” genre or choose from the top of the Apple Podcasts charts, then spend until the budget runs out.  But those charts only measure the audience size. ORBIT measures real performance. There are top-performing shows you may have never heard of, and which have niche audiences that could boost your brand in a big way.

Customize for the Customer – The extra mile matters. Top shows like Pod Save America go further with their host-read ads, which explains how the product works and why their audience should care. This deeper integration follows a trend seen by creators and brands throughout 2026: Creators are offering more touchpoints across their platforms, while brands crave closer partnerships and authentic endorsements. A perfunctory ad read won’t drive results.

Go Beyond CPMs – If you’re fixated on your media plan’s CPMs, you’re missing out on performance. “ We have shows that are crushing it for clients that are $80 CPMs,” explains Kyle. “We have other shows that are terrible at an $8 CPM.” While CPMs are great at telling you how many people (might) get your message, what you really want to know is how many people will be moved when they get it. Not to be a broken record, but you should build your plan from ORBIT’s performance data, not just from the cheapest impressions available.

For more data-driven insights gleaned from ORBIT’s latest findings, read the new report here. And for more of Kyle and Hilary’s expert analysis, check out the full episode below.


Your Monthly ORBIT Report – November 2026

Want the Best Shows? Look Past the “Best” Genres 

We’ve looked at the best shows in many genres, but what are the best shows across all of podcasting? To find out, we turned to ORBIT.

ORBIT (the Oxford Road Benchmark Intelligence Tool) isolates performance using actual campaign data representing over $2 billion in advertiser spend. Special shout-out to our top three performers: Good Life Project (#3), The Jordan Harbinger Show (#2), and the champion of champions, Crash Dummies Podcast with Pat and Mike (#1).

A few big takeaways from our best of the best performers:

  • There’s No Formula for Success. Good luck finding a pattern for efficient podcasts. The top shows hail from the comedy, education, self-improvement, true crime, news, technology, and sports genres. Because top shows crop up in very different formats, marketers can’t predict performance from categories. Our advice? Sample genres broadly, and use ORBIT performance data to pick which shows to scale, and which to scrap.

  • Untangle Averages to Find Outliers. On average, the comedy category isn’t a genre winner (see our Comedy ORBIT breakdown). Yet one out of three top performers overall is a comedy show. Same goes for the true crime category, which contributes another three of our top shows. The takeaway? Don’t count out any genre, especially high-variance ones like comedy, which can include everything from The Adam Carolla Show to The Weekly Show with Jon Stewart.

Craving nothing but the best for your campaign? For the complete November ORBIT Rankings and Insights, check out the full report below.

Get the full ORBIT November report here


The Classifieds

CFB Rivalry Week Is Here – This Show Lives for It

Network: Good Karma Sports
Episodic Downloads: 81,000

College Football’s rivalry week is almost here, which means grudges are being renewed and fans are counting down to kickoff. This week’s classifieds listings are for the football obsessives, featuring two shows that cover the college game from every angle. Our first entry comes from someone who has played the game at the highest level.

Former Alabama quarterback Greg McElroy hosts Always College Football, a collaboration between ESPN and Omaha Productions. The show offers analysis and opinions on top teams, interviews with coaches, and under-the-radar stories from coast to coast. If you want to reach passionate, year-round college football fans, this is a heavy hitter. Click the button below.

Get The Deal

College Sports Never Stops Here

Network: Rogue Media Sports Network
Episodic Downloads: 1,000

Our second listing keeps the energy high. 365 Sports College Countdown with Josh Neighbors, from Rogue Media Sports Network, covers all things college sports five days a week. Josh is often joined by KATV’s Jack Allen, and the two tackle everything from the AP poll and College Football Playoff changes to debates about the greatest college quarterbacks of all time (Tebow, Newton, and Vince Young all get a turn).

With college football rivalry games around the corner, there’s no shortage of material, and the daily episodes and fan-first approach make this show perfect for brands looking to reach sports fans all season long. Click the button below and get in the game.

Get The Deal


In Case You Missed It

Ad Load Up – Spend Up – Magellan’s Latest Podcast Numbers

Magellan AI estimates U.S. podcast ad spending rose 18% year over year in Q3 2026. The company identified 1,468 first-time podcast advertisers and noted that ads accounted for 8.86% of episode time on average (that’s an increase of more than 8 percent from a year earlier). If you’re planning a podcast investment, Magellan’s quarterly reports provide benchmarks for what brands in your category are spending, how long ads typically run, and where they’re placed. Those benchmarks can help you size a first test or assess an existing buy.

Read More

iHeart Denies Potential Podcast Sale, and Should

Bloomberg reports that iHeartMedia held preliminary discussions about selling part or all of its podcast business (iHeart denied having any plans to sell). The speculation follows disappointing company earnings, despite podcast revenue growing 24% to $174 million in Q3. iHeart also plans to report podcasting as a separate business segment in 2027. Podcasting is one of iHeart’s strongest businesses. While a sale could ease short-term financial pressure, it would also mean giving up a clear growth engine.

Read More

Podcast Catching Up to Radio for 18-34s

Nielsen’s Q3 report, based on Edison Research data, shows podcasts account for 33% of ad-supported audio listening time among adults 18–34, compared with 42% for radio. (The analysis excludes music and music-video listening on YouTube.) If you’re trying to reach adults under 35, buy podcasts from the get-go. If you want a peek at where the market is headed, look at how younger audiences consume content today.

Read More


#SaveTheLiveReads

Tecovas Boot Season Is an Event – Circling Back Agrees

Dillon Cheverere, David Ruff, and Will DeFries of Circling Back bring this week’s #STLR with an enthusiastic Tecovas endorsement that makes fall boot season feel like an event. The hosts share their excitement for cooler weather and the chance to break out their favorite pairs, and get specific about the styles they wear. They also praise how comfortable each pair feels straight out of the store, as if they’ve already been broken in for years. Beyond the boots themselves, the hosts highlight the in-store experience, from helpful staff and complimentary drinks to the option of having a new pair branded on the spot. It’s a lively read that brings the brand’s craftsmanship, comfort, and Western style to life.

Listen Here

Contact us for a Consultation 


OXFORd In The News

Barrett Put Granger in the Hot Seat & He Had a Lot to Say

Barrett Media published a lengthy interview with Oxford Road CEO Dan Granger, as part of the publication’s “Meet the Leaders” series. The Q&A covers everything from the state of the industry to the rise of AI to the creation of the AMP Accords, and you can read the whole thing here.

Read More

What Brands Want Is Making Noise Across the Industry

Radio Ink was one of several publications to highlight Oxford Road’s annual What Brands Want report, which surveys leading advertisers to learn about the opportunities (and obstacles) they’re seeing in the world of podcast, audio, and creator media. The What Brands Want report–which you can download here–was also covered by Inside Radio, Net Influencer, Roast Brief.

Read More


If you’ve read this far, thank you!

The Influencer is a production from the team at Oxford Road.
If you like our sometimes sassy, mostly informed POVs on the wonderful world of audio advertising, you should see what we do for our clients.

Interested in seeing how we could help your business?
Contact us at influencer@oxfordroad.com!

Thank you to the team that puts The Influencer together each week:

Ezra Fox – Media Roundtable & Ad Infinitum recap
Spencer Semonson – Classifieds
Neal Lucey – In Case You Missed It
Ashley Warmenhoven – Save The Live Reads

Editors:
Kyle Jelinek
Kristen Larson
Haley Wiese
Bianca Gorodinsky
Kelsey Odenthal
Brian Raftery

 

Categories

Newsletter

You May Also Like

This Week’s Influencer: Genre Is a Trap; Four Outlets Agree Measurement Is Broken; Honor a Veteran; CA, NY, and PA Now Regulate AI Ads; and More
This Week’s Influencer: What Brands Want 2026 Drops; Why You Shouldn’t Avoid News; Bad Data Buries Audio; SiriusXM Bets on Reach; and More…
This Week’s Influencer: Stew and Bethany on When Fear Becomes a Crutch; ORBIT Proves Good Ads Don’t Pick a Side; Substack Gets Serious; and More…
george costanza